this may seem like a strange debate outside of canada.

our bicameral legislature isn't modeled after the body in the united states, but is rather a direct evolution of the british system. so, we have a house of commons - a parliament - and something we call a "senate", which is really a house of lords. for decades, the house of lords came into disuse, reduced to patronage appointments for political expediency. and, it is true that it was a waste of money, but this was a minor concern in the larger scheme of things - reducing it to patronage appointments at least prevented it from being used to overturn the will of the house, which is the actual expression of democracy in the country.

the conservatives used to argue for an elected senate, but they haven't done that in a while. it is very quintessentially canadian of me to oppose this proposal, which is generally denigrated across the spectrum as an americanizing policy. our entire system of government was designed to try and prevent the gridlock that exists in the american system. i know that americans love their checks and balances in order to prevent tyranny, but, standing in canada, i'm willing to finger your broken system of government as the root cause of most of your social problems. i don't want to create a system where one house is fighting against the other all of the time. so, i am opposed to an elected senate for the reason that i don't want the gridlock and inefficiency inherent in the american system.

further, abolishing the senate would eliminate the only check that we have. we don't want the senate to actually do anything, except when it has to do something. again: this is very canadian of me.

but, a tanker ban is hardly the kind of pressing concern that needs to trigger an undemocratic seizure of the state, and an oil industry lobbyist is hardly the correct vehicle to overturn the democratic will of the country. the danger of maintaining the senate, always abstract and distant when it was kept in disuse, has now been made apparent and obvious, and freethinking peoples that uphold the primacy of the popular will must mobilize to prevent the country from falling further into tyranny.

the senate wasn't broken before, but it is now.

it must be abolished.