this is worth watching.
Tuesday, October 27, 2026
this is a video done by an iranian (i think) living in the west that addresses the issue directly. he usually focuses on geopolitics. his videos are of varying accuracy in terms of conclusions, but he is a good researcher.
at
22:46
it's possible that the indigenous algerian berbers had a story about their aristocracy arising from the ocean. it's a common meme in history that may have an ancient origin in the pre-neolithic danubian culture. other places it shows up in are
- the merovingian franks believed they were cimmerians. they also believed their aristocracy were fishmen that crawled out from the ocean. there is evidence of substantive western iranian migration into france in the migration period. the french name alain, and a spate of place names derived from it, is iranian in origin and the result of iranian migration into france.
- the sumerians, which probably spoke a pre-proto-indoeuropean dialect and may have origins in the black sea or danube river area, also believed their aristocracy came from the oceans.
this sumerian theory of fishman origin has been presented as a crude evolutionary theory, which is a bit of a stretch.
i have no supporting evidence, but it's possible that a similar theory was co-opted by muslim colonists in north africa and converted into a story about a syrian swimming across the sea. it's the same kind of syncretism that defines european christianity, but we've mostly figured it out through critical analysis, and they've mostly been ordered to submit and obey and not think it through. in fact, there's a convincing argument that the holy grail myth is based on a christianization of the merovingian mythology, to the idea of jesus' bloodline landing in marseilles (an ancient greek port built to export celtic goods, like salt and tin, back to greece).
at
22:26
do arabs do science?
well, there's a lot of arabs out there. there's a number of concepts of what an arab is out there; genetic, cultural, linguistic, imperial, colonial. there's a lot of science out there. there's been a lot of time passed since the plague ravaged the levant, a major war between rome and persia concluded and, when the dust settled, and in the absence of reliable historical narratives, the region emerges with an arab identity. the reality is we're not entirely sure what happened. the objective facts are the plague and the war, the rest is really in the realm of mythology. the muslim texts don't show up for a few hundred years after the roman nakbah in the region. the gap makes building history impossible. there's an extremely convincing argument that the new emperors in syria basically made the whole thing up c. 950 ish and that the historiography is 100% fictional up to the point, to the point of mohammed being effectively a plagiarized theft of jesus, who never even existed at all.
they call it a golden age, but it's a myth. the arab world emerged from it's own dark age with a series of mythological narratives after the collapse of charlemagne's empire. the mythology says they had a good time, and maybe they did - baths, book burnings, polygamy, even open homosexuality. hey. but it's all fictional.
if you don't believe me, go swim from syria to algeria. go do it. i'll bring the stop clock. that was probably a joke! it probably got lost as a joke and converted to history. the things like that - the white horse to heaven, which was stolen from the story of elijah in the book of kings, the swimming across the mediterranean, which is obviously ported greek or carthaginian mythology, etc - are so silly that they expose themselves as myth immediately. but the reality, which is less accepted or discussed, is that there's not a word in the historiography that's any better than this, and this situation of unreliable history in the muslim world persists until el cid. none of it is reliable. the byzantines were not better, either. there are lengthy periods of byzantine history where the official history states the history was rewritten. like, it's a historical fact that the historical record was erased and reconstructed.
the egyptians would erase people from their hieroglyphs. it wasn't rare.
so, it's an open question how seriously the history is intended to be taken in the first place and whether the religious lost the plot somewhere. if you go way back, people were certainly superstitious, but did anybody believe the story of elijah or of going to heaven on a horse? did anybody believe that god spoke to moses and gave him the ten commandments, that god spoke to mohammad and gave him the koran or that god spoke to joseph smith? the greek mythology is fun! it was supposed to be fun, and we didn't lose the plot. we read it as fun, today. did we lose the plot somewhere along the way with the judaic faiths?
is this actually kant's fucking fault? did they get it before kant decided history was perfect truth?
it's just another reason to prefer indo-european religion over judeo-christian-muslim religion.
so we don't know how it happened - not truly, not honestly - but the map just changed a bit before the year 1000. we woke up in a roman nightmare. the crusades start about the same time.
in that 1000 years, have there been some arab scientists? have there been kurdish scientists in baghdad that spoke and wrote in arabic? or spanish scholars, many carthaginian-jewish? i mean, sure.
the culture, however, was and remains brutally, brutally repressive.
so, do arabs do science? it's a big target. it's hard to miss, in absolute terms.
i get the impression that somebody is trying to quote dawkins, and that wasn't dawkins' argument. dawkins, who i would describe as a liberal in a hurry, and certainly not as a maga conservative, was drawing attention to the statistics. do arabs do science in aggregate? when they do do science, are they fighting against cultural norms? are they fighting against government censorship? are they putting their lives at risk?
there's no genetic reason why arabs ought to be disinterested in science. arabs ought to be as capable and interested in science as any other group, if raised in comparable environments.
however, there's a few reasons why they are culturally less inclined to science and why the religion makes them less likely to succeed as scientists. this has led to a statistically lower percentage of arabs winning nobel prizes and other awards than other groups. that's empirically true. it's simple math built on a basic observation. that was dawkins' point.
it may be difficult to tell from looking at his unkempt appearance and his visibly poor personal hygiene, which has him transporting bacteria across michigan on his face, call it the el sayad e coli express, but the democratic candidate in michgan was at one point a doctor. i don't question his credentials. i may point out that doctors are not empirical scientists. but i would expect that a doctor is less likely to fall into these traps than a general member of the arab population. to the extent that critiques of islam and science have merit, this guy might not be the best data point. there's consequently a valid concern about the application of stereotypes and discrimination. individual members of a population don't necessarily display the characteristics of those populations that exist in majority proportions.
the following are reasons why arab culture and the religion of islam make arabs less likely to become scientists:
- the authoritarianism
- the rejection of dissent and critical thought
- the philosophical preference for analytic philosophy, and a continuing aristotlian rut, over empirical observation, and the subsequent minimization of the scientific method
as many have pointed out, these issues can be addressed. we got over them in the west; or we thought we did. creeping catholicism, which trump has aligned himself with, is threatening to topple the enlightenment. we might be competing for most ignorant monkey with the arabs before too long, while the chinese finish what they started with genghis khan.
i'm hoping for communism instead but i'm no fucking clairvoyant. i'm not fooling anyone with no cosmic debris.
i'd call on dawkins to speak for himself. he's still alive. he is capable of articulating himself.
the comments are clearly racist and he shouldn't be taken out of context. to the extent that they are statistically valid, this individual might not be an appropriately representative sample. stereotypes can be silly and fun, but they can also be damaging and hateful.
to defend myself, this is what i was getting at when i argued that michigan will never elect an arab. trump might repulse a fair number of people with these comments, but michigan is actually a very segregated and very racist state. there's a lot of people in michigan that aren't going to find his comments revolting at all.
this isn't my fight and i'm not interested in it. i would have rather seen the democrats run a different candidate than have to go through this. i don't want to defend this guy against racist attacks. i don't like his culture much, either.
at
22:03
in 2026, people magazine is apparently a gay male lifestyle rag.
i promise you that a poll of straight women would decide that this is the most disgustingly ugly gay man they've ever seen by a margin of well over 80%.
at
20:12
i got a little done last night, but it was odds and ends, and planning things out, and i never really got started.
i should finish tonight for sure.
at
19:35
the bankers and conservatives want you to think france has some kind of debt problem. right.
rather, they seem to be insufficiently taxing their substantive wealth. i mean, this is france. it's a very rich country. the idea that it's drowning in debt it can't pay off is nonsense.
the way the eu is structured is a problem because it neither allows for sovereign debt nor does it allow for wealth redistribution. i've been careful about commenting on the bourgeois narrative around this, because i have a lot of criticism about how the eu operates. the entire media narrative from all directions has no grounding in facts or reality, so it's extremely difficult to find a way into it in terms of finding a position to criticize. france has enough economic capacity that it should be able to run larger deficits without concerning itself about it, but the structure of the eu places artificial restrictions on debt financing government budgets. the winner is private debt holders, many of them located overseas, that get interest payments from french taxpayers as some kind of foreign tribute on what should be sovereign debt. it's unsustainable, but the solution is reforming the eu, not austerity (as macron is enforcing or le pen wants to continue) or "cancelling the debt", as melenchon is running on, but can't actually do.
in the short run, until the eu can be reformed to allow for greater budget deficits and more wealth redistribution, the only remaining solution is localized tax increases (to pay for out of control war spending in africa and generous handouts (or loans) to ukraine, which could be cut to save substantive amounts of money upfront very easily), but the parliament is blocking it. it indicates an intentional desire to redistribute wealth upwards.
there's plenty of money for war, there's plenty of money for "foreign aid", there's plenty of money for interest payments to foreigners and there's plenty of wealth that could be taxed. the narrative that there's no money for schools or pensions is consequently a rather blatantly transparent lie being enforced by the banking class, which the media is faithfully parroting.
that said, i'm not convinced that the schools are underfunded to begin with, but the money to hike spending is there, if they do make that choice. don't believe that france is too poor to pay for it's kids or elderly. that's absurd.
at
19:13
the israeli election is a mess.
likud (netanyahu's party) won the most seats by a large margin, but neither bloc is anywhere close to a majority. there is something illegitimate about a minority party that lost the election taking power. but somebody needs to get 10-12 more seats. somebody needs to blink.
neither block is left or even centrist. they're both very conservative blocks, and it's more a question of personality than politics. for that reason, the most correct outcome is for netanyahu to stay in power, because he still won the election, and there's no mandate to reverse that. somebody in the opposing block - probably lieberman's party - is going to have to flip.
essentially, what happened is that netanyahu threw lieberman out of the coalition for being an ass (opposing a ceasefire) and now he can't get back to a majority without him, but neither can the opposition. netanyahu and lieberman are going to have to work their shit out.
at
18:54
it turns out "ai" is a good excuse to block people that use adblockers.
ai doesn't bother me that much, but cloudfare has thoroughly destroyed the internet. i was surfing at higher speeds in the 90s. it's worse than uac.
at
18:35
this is media sensationalism at it's worst and is based in denialist science about "planetary waves" that isn't explained to the reader. it's the worst kind of click bait. i would recommend the government run weather service over the weather network, as it doesn't engage in this kind of free market profiteering bullshit.
the increase in solar radiation that broke up last winter's polar vortex, in conjunction with the increase in carbon in the atmosphere (more concentrated in the north and south) was very intense and led to a higher level of disorganization than normal. long term climate change models predict the near to total destruction of the polar vortex as a yearly phenomenon. the blasts of cold air that we've been experiencing over the last few years are a last gasp of the arctic, and a symptom of an arctic that is ultimately collapsing under the pressure of an increased greenhouse effect. there's no ice caps on venus at all.
every time the polar vortex collapses in the summer, there's a possibility it won't be able to reform.
the development of the polar vortex requires an immense change in energy that is working against thermodynamics, and a natural increase in entropy. it's really something that shouldn't happen, and it only happens because the sudden decrease in light starting after sept 21st leads to such an immense plunge at such a fast rate. the polar night hits a peak of darkness, and an absence of sunlight, at the end of december.
as the greenhouse effect traps more and more heat into the atmosphere, the polar vortex will become less and less likely to form and will in the end not form at all. when we get to that point, it will no longer come apart in the arctic winter and the hemispheric spring, and we will no longer get blasts of cold air falling south at the end of the polar night, as a consequence of the sun's energy returning to the poles.
in the long term, once all of the cold has been warmed up past a certain point, winter won't happen anymore at all. in the short term, when the polar vortex is only beginning to fail, what will happen is something similar to what you're seeing right now - decreases in sunlight after sept 21st will lead to colder temperatures, but the increased greenhouse effect will prevent the polar vortex from forming. the result is more dispersion of less intense cold air, with increasing decreases in intensity and dispersion, until the polar vortex ceases altogether.
you're consequently actually seeing the beginning of the end of the polar vortex, but the high profile collapses have been signalling this has been on it's way for a while. this is not surprising at all. it's a clear consequence of the climate change models, and we've been watching it build up for years.
the first year where the polar vortex does not form due to a strengthened greenhouse effect will be a major tipping point for the planet's climate. it is probably not this year. however, the trends are clearly pointing in that direction and it might be sooner than anybody imagines.
but the capitalists want to sell you on an ice age or something. click. click. click. buy. buy. buy.
at
17:41
the result in mississaugua, which is a sprawling suburb of toronto full of 6 or 7 figure mansions, was due to two right-wing women splitting the vote. this is a city that has been run by conservative women for decades.
turnout was also 30%.
i would expect that mississaugua will elect another conservative woman at it's soonest opportunity. and she'll probably be white.
at
17:15
i'm also sick and fucking annoyed of this idea of boycotting israel.
i want to turn the tables and request that broad swathes of society organize total boycotts against "palestine" and against any individual, entity, body or group that supports "palestine". supporting "palestinian statehood" should be seen as completely unacceptable and aggressively cancelled, from this point.
do not engage in any sort of commerce, debate or interaction with any entity that supports "palestine". completely, totally boycott them until they cease to exist.
at
02:58
when the media nowadays talks about "foreign interference" the unstated implication is that this is some kind of bad thing because countries have "sovereignty". i dunno where this nonsense came from. it's some kind of property right of a localized elite to enslave their own population.
"go enslave your own people. you have no right to interfere with how i enslave mine.".
that's a bunch of bullshit. if it's in a state's self-interest to interfere in the affairs of another state, it should aggressively do so, and tell them to fuck off if they don't like it. i believe that i have a right to interfere in the affairs of any foreign state that i choose, if it is in my self-interest, and i won't be told otherwise. go fuck yourselves. the only sovereignty i recognize is the sovereignty of the individual to make choices in it's individual self-interest.
i remember reading books written in the 50s or even in the 90s when the perspective was entirely different. it was just understood that everybody spies on each other. nobody gave it a second thought. it was just a fact of reality.
when did "foreign interference" become something to get upset about rather than a triviality to shrug off?
at
02:54
the low vacancy rate (i don't care about buying houses. i'm poor. complaints about difficulties entering the housing market or housing prices in general are completely irrelevant and of no interest to me. they are only of any minimal interest in the sense that cheap new houses would reduce pressure on the rental market, but people want to move from their parents' 4 bedroom houses to their own. they don't want starter houses and don't understand how equity works.) in canada is not due to immigration or supply. this is a false dichotomy.
the low vacancy rate is due to high immigration and low supply.
it would be nice to build more apartments, but the political system is stacked against it, which is why it's not happening. it isn't not happening due to an insufficient supply of labour; that has nothing to do with it. it's not happening because single-family property owners elect city council members that block it. rich people hate renters and don't want them in their wards. the absence of affordable apartment buildings is because rich property owners don't want affordable apartments, not because we don't have enough people to build them. rather, more immigration at the lower end of the market just places more stress on the market, and leads to higher rents, so rich property owners that survive by extracting rent will continue to dump more poor people on the market in order to maximize their rentier extraction, and then argue they can't build more housing because there's not enough labour. that's a myth. it's false. what is true is that the propertied class wants higher rents, so it supports high immigration levels and opposes the construction of new housing, to increase demand and restrict supply. there's no crisis of labour when it comes to building new condos, or building giant houses in the suburbs. the crisis of insufficient labour is only trotted out as a myth and a canard and an excuse to explain the absence of affordable housing. it's complete and utter bullshit - they're just trying to hike the rent by flooding the market, and then coming up with a bullshit excuse as to why they won't build more housing. yet, this is so entrenched that it's almost impossible to address, and there's essentially no hope of resolving the issue by building more housing.
so, it's a lot easier and more realistic to block immigration.
the basic point is that immigrants benefit the wealthy at the expense of the poor. that's the economics of it. all of the arguments in favour of immigration are good for rich people - it's true - but bad for poor people. the second part of the argument gets lost because the media doesn't care about what poor people want.
the ndp pretends to represent the poor but their policies consistently benefit the rich. it has never presented any kind of cogent reason as to why it supports immgration, it has only ever come up with canards and excuses and myths to explain why it opposes those who oppose immigration. well, the reason is that immigration benefits the rich. that's why they support it.
it makes sense for ndp voters to swing right on this issue and that shift isn't going to lift with rhetoric or reverse any time soon. this is about class interests.
the ndp needs to readdress the class interests around immigration and drop the bourgeois nonsense about "racism" and "diversity". those are just rhetorical excuses that the rich uses to attack the poor with. at a point of economic stress, historical ndp voters are seeing through these myths and rhetorical excuses and seeking policies aligned with their class interests and the ndp are failing to provide those policies.
the results are not going to be in the interests of those voters in the long run, but it's at the least a valid expression of anger at policies that are not working for working class people.
at
01:59
there was a noticeable electoral result in hamilton, a large city in the golden horseshoe region of the greater toronto census region. you can bicycle from toronto to hamilton and back without exiting an urban zone, if you have all fucking day to waste. that's not the norm in canada, where population centres are generally separated by large, sprawling green spaces. in that sense, oshawa/toronto/mississaugua/oakville/burlingon/hamilton is really one big city around the lake, with hamilton located at the southwest corner of the lake.
the outgoing mayor of hamilton was badly defeated by a right-wing challenger. she only managed 14%. just a few years ago, she was running for premier of ontario; she was the leader of the ontario ndp for quite a lengthy period and had a lot of influence during the minority phase of the wynne government.
what happened?
all evidence suggests it's the drugs in hamilton, which, like many places in ontario, has seen a stark increase in drug addiction since the pandemic as a result of inflation, immigration, "harm reduction", lingering pandemic restrictions and austerity measures converging into a perfect storm for drug addicts. you could previously afford to live on disability in this province, be a drug addict and get housed. you could even do it on welfare if you could find the right supports. you can't do that anymore - less because of inflation and more because housing availability crashed, due to a combination of population increases (almost entirely due to immigration) and insufficient supply being generated to meet it. if you get evicted here now, and you have addictions problems, you may find it extremely difficult to impossible to get housed without going through the homeless shelter system, and they won't let you stay there unless you're cleaned up, and in the end they'll stick you in some insufficient hole in the wall. so, you end up in a tent, which means you don't vote when it's time. both sides of the political equation are fed up with the established left on this. the poor (including the addicts) want less immigration and more housing, and the conservatives want more policing and less tolerance for the drug use. horwath seems to have decided to run on abortion instead, which is just totally bizarre. it's like she just gave up and everybody could see her giving up in real time.
so hamilton, a union town and often an ndp stronghold, has a new very conservative mayor, and bafflingly voted 85% for the right, in a total rejection of harm reduction and immigration at the same time.
how much of this is fair and how much of it is voters being dumb?
it's mostly voters being dumb. they won't get what they want from this outcome. they're likely to get cuts n services, and the result is predictable: it won't last long.
but the truth that ndp politicians need to grasp is that the formula on addiction presented by the pseudo-left isn't working. harm reduction isn't working and housing isn't keeping up. everybody's fed up and looking for somebody to blame. horwath had a target on her back due to her experience in toronto, and her identification with the ndp.
the ndp needs to adjust it's messaging on addiction and it's consequences if it wants to return as a competitive political force in the areas it used to dominate.
at
00:25
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
