Saturday, August 22, 2026

if you want to keep with the stupid hockey analogies, trump is a bully but he's also what hockey people call an enforcer. what that means is that a big part of what he's about is yelling stupid shit at you to get into your head to throw you off.

a canadian response of dollar-for-dollar tariffs might be the consequence of international capital colluding across borders to create a targeted attack on the north american working class.

or it might be trump's constant chirps throwing carney off his game.

either way, i hope the pmo rethinks this.

tariffs are not inherently dumb, but they are hard and they are usually dumb and usually backfire. what i've heard so far sounds like dumb tariffs that are going to backfire.
i don't doubt that canada needs a good, careful, well thought through response that should include keynesian spending (primarily), increases in investment, targeted tax cuts, export taxes, subsidies, retraining programs and, perhaps, extremely minimal tariffs.

what i've been hearing from mr. carney so far is not that. insisting on dollar-for-dollar tariffs is not rational, it's hot-headed and emotional and irrational. it's what trump wanted and got, either through collusion or manipulation. carney has let trump get into his head and throw him off.

it's passion over reason.
while i don't have a rigorous opposition to taxing american industrial equipment (an economist would call this capital investment) for sectors like agriculture, i do have some questions as to it's effectiveness and whether it's a rational counter policy.

it would seem to me that hiking the price of equipment in the agriculture sector, which i would presume means things like tractors, is going to in the end increase the price of canadian food products, either by forcing producers to shift the costs to consumers or by forcing producers to buy more expensive canadian machinery, when it is even available at all. there is going to be some percentage of this equipment that just is not made here.

i am not a farmer, but my understanding is that the way this works today is that farmers sign contracts with machinery manufacturers, who will actually send techs to the farms to install the equipment. the farmers don't do much farming anymore, it's contracted out to what are essentially technology companies. if these farmers are locked into 10 or more year contracts, they might not have the ability to opt out. the stated goal of coercing canadian farmers to buy canadian machinery to replace american machinery might therefore not be realistic. if they do go down that path, it might literally costs millions of dollars to turn it over.

the likely result of taxing american equipment is consequently going to be inflation in the price of canadian food, making canadian products less competitive. this is the classic mistake ricardo (a socialist, btw) warned about, and exactly the kind of dumb policy that trump has been implementing. this is why i'm accusing carney of being trump-lite. to fight trump, he's become trump, and that's a slippery slope to catastrophe.

it would seem to me that a better - and more traditionally liberal capitalist - approach would be to provide tax cuts for canadian firms and farmers when they buy canadian capital investment, instead of to tax american equipment on the way in. that's the sort of policy you would expect from an economist, not a tariff on foreign made capital investment. that's actually a terrible economic policy, from any liberal capitalist ideological position.

if you just become the thing you hate, you aren't actually fighting it.

i may have little interest in this and not care much for keeping up with competitive bouts between international capital firms, like blackrock, but i don't want to pay higher prices for bread to prop up some fucker's trust fund.

one easy way to get around this is to bring back the wheat board in it's previous role. canadian farmers are going to be selling less to the american market. that would provide price stability in the short term.
i want to lay down a spectrum on this and i'm going to over-simplify it.

the right should respond to this with nationalism and patriotism and see the conflict as one between two nations, canada and the united states.

the left should be critical of this and should instead see the conflict as having to do with class. they should see an attack on workers on both sides of the border and try to build a transnational working class response to an attack by international capital.
i broadly support government spending on housing and climate change transition and mitigation. i can support that. 

i don't like mark carney very much. i don't like how he talks, his rhetoric, his turns of phrase. he really leaves me with cold with his mannerisms. i wouldn't want to have a beer with this guy.

let me tell you what i like about what he said.

- he indicated that the counter-tariffs won't target food but will rather be focused on industrial equipment. 
- he seems to realize that the solution to this attack - he suggested we're at war - is keynesian spending and has identified houses and electricity grids as things to fund. he didn't talk about military spending. i hope the next thing on the list is climate change mitigation, from sea walls to water bombers.

i can't tell you if he made the right choice. i haven't seen the details. but my concern is how this stupid competitive behaviour affects low income canadians, and i don't hear any red flags.

i will tentatively withdraw my demand for a non-confidence vote, pending clarification on what's actually about to get taxed.
some american goods i might support higher taxes on:

- guns
- cars
- clothes
- video games
- movies and tv shows
- alcohol (why don't you tax it instead of ban it?)
- cigarettes
- bibles
- gambling of any and all sorts
- internet video and news sites
- ticket sales for american performers of any types, including american sports teams. for example, a taylor swift concert ticket in toronto or a canadiens-bruins hockey game in montreal would have a tariff surcharge.
- salaries of american athletes playing in canada. so, an american signed to a toronto sports team would have to forfeit a percentage of their salary as a tariiff/tax.

i would support going ahead with a carbon tax on american imports, that levies higher taxes on dirtier goods, whatever they are.

the idea is you tax things you don't like.

but don't tax food. that makes the poor pay for the rich, and it's about time that working people on both sides of this artificial border stood up to that and said "enough".
a 50% tax on food by the federal government is a good reason for working class canadians to take to the streets and burn the government offices down.
if my government wants to hike taxes on imported food to try to force me to buy local food, my response is "fuck you", and i'm going to boycott the local producers and fight to tear down the state rather than be coerced into supporting local industry.

go fuck yourselves, nationalists.
you could look at the upside of this. what sectors are getting affected?

- lumber
- steel
- cars

if that means more trees and less pollution in canada, i'm not going to shed a tear for the loss of profits to some capitalist car company or something. we can retrain these people to do more environmentally responsible jobs.

i would like to see large export taxes on the sectors that trump exempted, which are the items the us needs and will pay for. that would include oil, uranium, potash, electricity, aluminum, etc. 

what i do not want to see is a tax hike on food staples like orange juice or coffee. i'd like to see more american food items, not less, because they have higher fortification levels, and health canada has become retarded in it's obsession about "over-fortification", which is not science but just stupid hippie bullshit.

i want to suggest to mr carney that he have a concept of class consciousness when drawing up these tariffs. there is some possibility that what we're dealing with is actually collusion and that what's happening is actually a coordinated attack on the north american working class on a level that we haven't seen since the 80s. that might be the right way for the left to frame this. if he does this the way that mr trump wants him to, we're going to have 50-100% inflation on basic grocery items, and that's going to be a stab to the throat of working people on both sides of the border. it's an opportunity to go out and march on the streets and revolt.

but if mr carney does this the smart way - something that mr trudeau couldn't figure out - the tariffs might get absorbed entirely by bad environmental actors and be directed at the wealthy, who can pay for it.

go ahead and tax luxury automobiles. whatever. who cares?

but don't fucking tax food. you fuckers.
i would encourage canadians to respond to the retaliatory tariffs by boycotting canadian producers, and leaving their money in the bank, instead, until this is done.

let's force a recession, canada. let's tear the system down.

and then let's get rid of this maga stooge in the pmo.
i am strongly opposed to retaliatory tariffs on american goods and would call for a vote of non-confidence in the house of commons to dissolve the government in response to this decision. 

retaliatory tariffs do not protect canadian sovereignty, they are a vicious attack on the canadian working class that will hike the cost of living and lead to immense job losses.

i neither want to buy more canadian goods nor do i want to pay higher taxes on american goods; i want to tear my government down and replace it with a new one.
canada should wait for a new us administration before signing any agreements with the united states.

if i was carney, i might even choose not to accept calls from donald trump or his cronies.
trump's dishonest negotiating process is predictable at this point.

1. he tells you his demands.
2. you probably reject them
3. he makes concessions verbally to get you to agree
4. then he writes an agreement with the initial demands he amended verbally

you're supposed to get tricked into signing for the initial demands after verbally agreeing to the concessions. but nobody should be tricked by this anymore. you have to demand he puts it in writing up front.

if you don't sign it, he accuses you of breaking the deal or walking back the concessions.