Thursday, October 29, 2026

what of "islamic tolerance"?

no.

the myth of islamic tolerance is about a tax. muslims would allow a minimal set of non-muslims called "people of the book" to exist if they paid the tax. they would be persecuted if they refused the tax. this meant jews, christians and a couple of syncretic religious ideas that come from jewish scripture but are none of the most populous three judaic offshoots. it didn't apply to hindus, zoroastrians, european pagans, central asian animists, buddhists or african religions - they were infidels that would need to be converted or enslaved.

how much "islamic tolerance" ever existed in one place at one time was variable and in constant flux. it was always a tentative, delicate idea.

in fact, muslim rulers from spain to baghdad had a tendency to enjoy crucifying christians. they seem to have thought it was funny or something.

there were a few muslim rulers that were relatively tolerant and a few that were bloodthirsty assyrians in character. it was generally somewhere in between, but it ran the spectrum.