the correct way for new york city to deal with explicitly pro-hamas/pro-nazi protesters is not with a police response or with tepid political "condemnations". this is new york city. the correct way to approach this is to mobilize on the ground and brutally, viciously beat the shit out of them on the street - to cut them down in public and show the world that nazis are not welcome on the streets of new york, and this is what happens when nazis go there and try to set up.
you don't deal with these people by being nice to them.
you have to bludgeon them. you have to cut them down.