Sunday, November 22, 2026
my understanding is that there was also a kermit version of piggy but reznor scrapped the track and just used the drum fills.
at
15:19
i always like the alternate version of piggy, which was called peggy, and was sung by al bundy.
hey peg.
nothing's turned out the way i planned.
hey peg!
there's a lot of things i hoped you could help me understand.
(for all my disdain for the fuckers, i should have been a journalist. that was a pristine segueway.)
at
15:03
this is a very atr-influenced rick rubin mix of the nine inch nails track "piggy", released in 1995. it's arguably a missing link between the industrial/punk origins of brickwall limiting and the corporate rock in the 00s that overdid it, and which rubin (and ken marshall, who came from the skinny puppy / nettwerk records vancouver scene) is often blamed for.
if you want to hear some heavy limiting on vocals, go get too dark park.
but this nin track (with dave navarro on guitar) is supposed to sound like this. yes, it clips. yes, it's outrageously loud and incredibly obnoxious. some may find it "fatiguing". that's the point.
don't try to undo that by buying a vinyl version that had to hack the mix up to get it into the grooves. enjoy it for what it is or go listen to something else that you like better.
at
14:53
if you're the type of guitarist that chains a half dozen distortion effects together in order to maximize gain, and you want it to sound as demented and distorted as possible, you need a limiter at the end of the chain. you might damage your gear or even blow up your amps if you skip it. and, no, you don't want to turn it down. choosing to get your guitars as much gain as possible and then crushing it with a limiter at the end is a valid artistic decision, and if listeners find that "fatiguing" they should shut the fuck up, fuck off, kill themselves and listen to some other record instead, first.
likewise, you can't record screamo vocals without a limiter of some sort.
i do have some cds from this period that are very loud, are loud on purpose and that sound better loud than they would if somebody tried to cut the volume. some people may be "fatigued" by this, but i guess it's just too complicated for them, and they should go listen to a joni mitchell record instead. i like the complexity, myself - and it was created with that mind. i have no desire to undo sound design choices by artists i respect.
where the issue may have gotten a little out of hand for a few years had to do with pop musicians adopting techniques designed to record loud music with, and the result was like this video, which i'm sure you remember:
i'd rather listen to the drummer than the band. don't get a new drummer. turn the vocals down. the drummer's the only good thing about the band.
but, it doesn't fit, and that's what the problem was - engineers tried to make bad pop music sound edgy by using hardcore punk mastering techniques and the pop fans didn't like it and wanted their pop music back.
but, i mean, that was 20 years ago. it doesn't matter anymore, and it's not an issue if you listen to real music (where the technique was never misapplied) or actually listen to actual hardcore punk artists, which actually needs to use these tactics to properly record the music they make.
if you really need a good copy of that shitty corporate 00s record that was mastered too loudly, then, ok, but it's certainly not worth downgrading your playback system or reverting back to 20th century technology over.
at
14:22
i can't think of anything in my cd collection that has over limited mastering effects applied to it - neither as an intentional artistic decision or as a stupid trend. of the thousand cds on my shelf, and the two or three thousand more i'me familiar with, i can't think of even one where the loudness wars issue is relevant.
.....because i don't listen to shitty music.
sorry.
so, i'll keep my cds, thanks.
at
13:18
is there any truth at all to this goofy, backwards argument that sound fidelity is dependent on the master rather than the playback mechanism?
i have a vague understanding that what ended up happening through the 00s is that some corporate sellout whore type bands picked up on that underground punk sound as "cool" and sought to emulate it in ways that lacked artistic depth. these band did not have the same aggravated attack in everything that justified the heavy limiting, they were just trying to sound like the cooler bands that did. this, unfortunately, was successful, which led to high album sales for those sellout bands and the identification of a trend in production that was copied over and over until it ended up on guns 'n' roses and eminem cds. then, it wasn't cool anymore, and it faded away.
i would suggest that there isn't. every time i've looked into this, my head just starts to hurt at trying to disentangle all of the mistakes in terminology dumb consumers are making. for example, they want to argue that vinyl has "more dynamics" because cds use "more compression". but that's utterly backwards. you have to compress the shit out of anything at all to get it into the grooves. the effect people are trying and failing to describe is that they prefer the higher compressed vinyl master to the less compressed cd master.
to the extent that there is any truth to it, it has to do with limiting and not with compression. limiting is not a type of compression. the argument is that some recording engineers used too much limiting in their masters (mostly on the vocals) and that the higher compression in the vinyl mastering process (as opposed to the lower amount of compression used to master cds) reduces the effect of the limiters.
well, ok.
first off, you should stop listening to shitty music mastered by bad engineers if you think that's a legitimate problem. leave the records in the trash heap of history and keep your superior cds and then get better taste in music, instead.
but if i'm to imagine some examples of this, i'm thinking mostly of punk and metal bands that actually intended for the record to have heavy limiting because they're constantly screaming into mics and playing guitars through chained distortion effects. this was an intentional artistic process in the late 90s and early 00s in a small subset of hardcore punk music to prevent dynamics in favour of a massive head cave. i don't want to undo that by downgrading to a more primitive form of technology, i want to listen to the record the way it was mixed to be listened to.
i have a vague understanding that what ended up happening through the 00s is that some corporate sellout whore type bands picked up on that underground punk sound as "cool" and sought to emulate it in ways that lacked artistic depth. these band did not have the same aggravated attack in everything that justified the heavy limiting, they were just trying to sound like the cooler bands that did. this, unfortunately, was successful, which led to high album sales for those sellout bands and the identification of a trend in production that was copied over and over until it ended up on guns 'n' roses and eminem cds. then, it wasn't cool anymore, and it faded away.
to the extent that it might have been a halfways convincing argument if applied to this handful of cds released by bad, trendy hipster artists in the early part of the century, i would reiterate that you should listen to better music instead of downgrading your playback technology.
to the extent that it applies to the bands that originated the sound, you are doing them and yourself a disservice by trying to add dynamics to the master. they took them out on purpose.
further, it wouldn't apply to music recorded before this bad trend in bad music took hold or music recorded since.
so, if you're concerned about "loudness wars" limiting affecting cd mastering and trying to get around it by buying vinyl instead, i'd suggest you don't do that.
1. stop listening to shitty music. if you had better taste in music, this wouldn't be a problem in the first place.
2. keep your cd masters of refused and atr records and other decent bands from the late 90s and early 00s that crushed the fuck out of the mixes on purpose. it's supposed to sound like that. it's not my thing, but the absence of dynamics in these recordings is an intentional artistic decision and you're killing the art by downgrading the playback to look for an sss on a cymbal crash or shape to vocals that were decimated intentionally.
3. it doesn't apply to older music and it doesn't apply to newer music. don't buy new vinyls and argue it's to save the dynamics. and don't buy old vinyls in rummage sales looking for broader dynamic range. that perspective is scientifically wrong and you won't get what you're searching for by doing that.
at
13:16
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)